Evolution and Speciation           (IB Topic A4.1)

Essential Idea(s): Evolution encompasses heritable changes in populations that drive the process of speciation.

Unit Length: 4 Lessons (+1 AHL)

  Guiding Questions

◊ What is the evidence for evolution?

◊ How do analogous and homologous structures exemplify commonality and diversity?

IB Statement(s) and Objective(s)

 

A4.1.1:  Evolution as change in the heritable characteristics of a population

  • Define evolution
  • Contrast Darwinian evolution with Lamarckism 
  • NOS Concept: The nature of science makes it impossible to formally prove that evolution is true by correspondence

 

A4.1.2:  Evidence for evolution from base sequences in DNA or RNA and amino acid sequences in proteins

  • Explain how DNA sequence data gives evidence of common ancestry
  • Outline the relationship between evolutionary relationships and biological sequences (using both nitrogenous bases and amino acids)

 

A4.1.3:  Evidence for evolution from selective breeding of domesticated animals and crop plants

  • Use an example to explain how selective breeding has led to evolution in a species
  • Explain the process of artificial selection using selective breeding

 

A4.1.4:  Evidence for evolution from homologous structures

  • Define homologous structures
  • Define speciation
  • Define pentadactyl limb
  • Explain how the pentadactyl limb serves as an example of evolution
  • List the bone structures present in the pentadactyl limb

 

A4.1.5:  Convergent evolution as the origin of analogous structures

  • Define analogous structures
  • Define convergent evolution
  • Contrast convergent evolution and divergent evolution
  • Define vestigial structure
  • State an example of a vestigial structure

 

A4.1.6:  Speciation by splitting of pre-existing species

  • Define speciation
  • Define gradualism
  • Identify gradualism from graphs of morphology changes over time

 

A4.1.7:  Roles of reproductive isolation and differential selection in speciation

  • Define reproductive isolation
  • Describe the process of speciation
  • Describe the evolutionary history of chimpanzees and bonobos as an example of divergence due to differential selection

Additional Higher Level Topics

A4.1.8:  Differences and similarities between sympatric and allopatric speciation

  • Compare allopatric and sympatric speciation
  • Outline temporal and behavioral isolation as mechanisms of speciation

 

A4.1.9:  Adaptive radiation as a source of biodiversity

  • Define adaptive radiation
  • Give an example of adaptive radiation
  • Define ecological niche
  • Describe how adaptive radiation can enhance biodiversity

 

A4.1.10:  Barriers to hybridization and sterility of interspecific hybrids as mechanisms for of preventing the mixing of alleles between species

  • Define ecological hybridization
  • Give an example of a hybridized species
  • Explain the frequent sterility of interspecific hybrids
  • Define courtship behavior
  • Outline how courtship behavior can prevent hybridization

 

A4.1.11:  Abrupt speciation in plants by hybridization and polyploidy

  • Define polyploidy
  • Explain how polyploidy can lead to speciation
  • Use smartweed (genus Persicaria*) to explain an example of abrupt speciation by hybridization and polyploidy

Activities: ⓟ = podcast / ⍰ = inquiry 5 / ⓦ = Write it /  Ӕ = The academy  / Ⓡ = Read it

Activities for SL: 

Virtual lab ⓟ/ⓦ/Ӕ: Exploring Lizard Phylogeny with DNA 

(💁 [written] / 👭 [podcast only] max 2)

Jump into the Caribbean to see how anole lizards have been evolving to local climates (e.g. the canopy of a tree vs. the forest floor) for millions of years. Complete Module 2 of this virtual lab – you may answer the accompanying questions either as a podcast or a written assignment. Work your way through this document as you go (remember to only do either module 2 or module 3). Here are the relevant documents to complete your module:

 

ⓦ/ⓟ: “Inquiry 5″: Q&A on Evolution & Speciation (💁/ 👭max 2 [podcast only])

Create a list of 5 inquiry questions related to speciation. Remember that good inquiry questions are conceptual / open-ended, 

SUCH AS: “How is speciation different from evolution?; 

NOT: “What is a gene pool?” 

If working solo, write out answers to your own questions; if working in pairs, record yourselves asking each other your 5 questions

 

ⓟ/ⓦ (+NOS): Dinosaurs Live On! (💁/ 👭max 2 [podcast only])

It still surprises a lot of people, but for over a decade now, scientists have confirmed the following: Dinosaurs are still alive and living amongst us. In a somewhat disappointing twist, they never went away – they simply survived the extinction. Yes, we’re talking about birds: the direct, living descendants of the dinosaurs. Watch this video on the evolution of dinos to birds, (or this one), read this short article, and then come up with a list of questions to discuss. Here are some suggested questions: 

  • How and why did birds end up being the only surviving dinosaurs?
  • Explain the details of how speciation took place in dinosaurs as they evolved into birds.
  • What evolutionary factors contributed to the survival of birds after the other dinosaurs died?
  • How the continuing study of dinosaurs leads to discoveries – such as the theory that many dinosaurs had feathers – that serve as perfect examples of the Nature of Science.

Feel free to come up with others – remember that the stronger the questions, the stronger the activity! 

 

ⓟ/ⓦ : Mini-Godzillas and the Continuing Evolution of the Galapagos (💁/ 👭max 2 [podcast only])

The marine iguana is one of a kind – it is the world’s only sea lizard. And… the lizard is found only in the Galapagos islands, the same home of Darwin’s finches. They were land animals when they first arrived, but quickly had to adapt to an all algae diet. Watch the linked videos and come up with a list of inquiry questions to discuss in your writing/podcast. Here are a few suggested questions: 

  • How is speciation at work in the marine iguana – what factors drove their adaptive history?
  • Discuss what kind of isolation took place within marine iguanas and their closest relatives?
  • How and why might the Galapagos serve as the sole destination for sea lizards in the world?

————————————-

Activities for AHL: 

ⓟ/ⓦ: How Mammals Raced to Fill Dinosaurs’ Void

It was one of the worst days for life in all of Earth’s 4.6 billion year history: a large asteroid ended dinosaur dominance, almost in an instant. It also, however, ended up being quite the opportunity for our mammalian ancestors. Read this article about a recent fossil dig site in Colorado, and/or watch this 15-minute video, and come up with a list of questions to explore the concepts from this unit. Here are a few suggested questions: 

  • Use your new knowledge of evolution and speciation to explain how and why the asteroid impact presented a golden opportunity for mammals.
  • Why are scientists still not entirely certain about the first mammal that emerged post-asteroid?; 
  • Why is this recent fossil dig site in Colorado so important in telling mammals’ ancestral story?; 
  • How fast did mammals evolve after the asteroid (and is this slower/faster than “normal” evolution)?

Feel free to use this accompanying worksheet to inspire some ideas for discussion.

 

Lab Design ⓟ/ⓦ: The Phylogenetics of Human History

(💁/ 👭max 2 [podcast only])

Imagine you have just been hired as an evolutionary biologist at the Smithsonian’s Museum of Natural history, home to one of the most extensive collections of fossil remains from hominids (human-like species) in the world.

Your task is to design a methodology to organize the evolutionary history of these specimens. (Keep in mind…you are only to propose a general methodology you could use if given access to these fossils). For this activity, you will need to write: 

  • A research question – What are you aiming to learn by sequencing. 
  • Clear variables, including: an independent variable, a dependent variable, and all relevant control variables. 
  • An introduction/background section – summarize what is known about the evolution of human species, and how fossils support the story of this evolution. 
  • A hypothesis – What do you expect the fossil remains to tell you? (Hint: Consider both genetic similarities and geographic locations that each fossil was found in).

A methodology – What steps would you take to map the evolutionary history of humans? (Hint: This must make use of genetic sequencing tools, such as those covered in A3.1.11